I’ve spent a lot of time in and around EA hiring for Bay Area and NYC tech startups and VCs. I’ve interviewed 1,000+ EAs over the past 15 years, and I’ve seen what gets people a strong yes… and what gets them a no.
I thought it could be helpful insight to share what I’ve learned by pulling direct quotes. Here are real reasons (copied and pasted in no particular order) why candidates have been declined, some of them before they even got a conversation, and my thoughts on each of them.
“An EA's LinkedIn is their first work product. If it's unpolished and generic, their board decks and exec communications will be, too.”
I kinda agree with this. Nowadays, 20% of my clients ask for candidate resumes. Most look at LinkedIn profiles instead. If your LinkedIn profile is messy, unorganized, too wordy, inconsistent in formatting, showcases bad judgment, has mistakes, then are you as “detail oriented” as you say you are in your about me section? Your LinkedIn profile is a reflection of who you are.
“I’d like to pass on this candidate based on backchannel feedback.”
Oof, I hear this so much. The startup tech and VC industries in the Bay Area and NYC are so small. SO. SMALL. Backchanneling on most candidates is so easy to do these days. This is why I tell EAs all the time to work hard, help others, be kind, be positive, and be great to work with. Because you never know if 5, 10 years later, someone reaches out to a past coworker of yours, whom you thought you’d never need or encounter again, to backchannel you.
“They look like my ex-girlfriend.”
Well shit, bro. I meannnnn………
“They took too long to respond to my email. I need someone who has a sense of urgency and checks email regularly.”
Touché. I agree with this. If you are taking days to respond, it shows you’re not excited about the role (unless of course some emergency happened or you’re on vacation, which you would have told the recruiter anyway, so those don’t count). Clients often times test candidates to see how long it will take them to respond. I’ve had some folks email in the evening just to see if they’ll get a response then. Often times, they’re looking for responsiveness as a quality in their EA. Your interview starts the moment that email intro is made.
“Claude is better than an average EA so people are going to have to try harder.”
This quote was in response to a candidate’s assessment. It was clear that AI did the work and not much human thought or energy or experience was put into it. I know the assessments for all these open EA roles can get ridiculous. They take hours to complete. And many of us have done multiple. It’s enticing to use AI to save time, but we can tell, you can tell, everyone can tell. Leaving you with another quote from the same person that I thought was actually quite wise: “Nobody comfortable now will still have a job unless you are in a super critical role that AI can’t do for a very long time.”
“They spent the whole interview revealing personal information about their current boss. I’m not hiring someone who lacks this much self awareness, judgement, and discretion.”
I have no words. Why on earth would you do that as a potential candidate interviewing for a role that requires the utmost discretion?
“Their personality won’t match with our CEO’s.”
Unfortunately, when this happens, there’s nothing you can do as a candidate. We can’t all match with everyone. It’s like dating. You don’t swipe right on everyone. Some people are your cup or tea. Others are not. That’s just human nature, and it is what it is.
“They rambled a lot and couldn’t organize their thoughts and answers.”
One of the most important pieces of advice an old boss gave me was “always be interviewing, not because you’re unhappy here, but because it helps to practice”. So I also tell this to everyone. Practice your story, write down your crazy experiences, remember the huge mistakes you’ve made so you can talk about them, learn how to speak about your career succinctly but thoroughly, and pause before answering if you must.
“I didn’t get the sense that they would go above and beyond what’s asked of them.”
This was probably because the candidate lacked stories and examples. This is also why it’s important to practice your story and organize your thoughts. If you are the type of EA who goes above and beyond, it will show naturally in how you answer the questions. I remember one candidate telling me “I don’t get paid to go above and beyond” and I was blown away by this. With that attitude and mindset, how do they expect to move higher in their career?
“She was really hung up on the hybrid work. We felt like we wouldn’t be able to rely on her if we needed her 5 days in office.”
This is a topic of conversation I have with a LOT of EAs right now. So many people want to be remote. But very few EAs can be a stellar remote EA. Many also want to be hybrid, 3 days in office. Maybe 4. What’s interesting to me is how many candidates are not flexible on this at all. To me, an EA role is about finding the right connection with the executive and working at a company I’m excited about. But to many others, they don’t care where they work or who they support as long as they get to be remote or hybrid. Everyone has their own reasons for why they want to be remote or hybrid, I get it, but in some situations, the entitlement is shocking to me. If you’re in your 20s, you should be going into the office everyday and working harder than anyone else. Now’s the time for you to shine, hustle, grind, have no work life balance, build a reputation, learn what you like and what you don’t like, build relationships.
“They were very difficult to connect with.”
To me, this can be two sided. Sometimes it’s the exec who is the one that’s difficult to connect with, so I take this type of comment with a grain of salt. With that said, a candidate’s job is to put their best foot forward in an interview. You want to come across as warm, friendly, knowledgable. You want to be likable and easy to get along with. You have 30 minutes (on zoom most of the time) to show someone what you might be like when people at the company first meet you. Most of the time, that first interview is never really about your actual experience. It’s about whether you’re a culture fit or not and whether you are immediately likable or not.
“They knew nothing about our company.”
Please come prepared to an interview. Reading a little bit about the company is interviewing 101. You don’t need to know everything about their product, but you should read a few articles, watch a few videos of the exec you’d support (if you know this info and they’re a public figure), and prepare a couple questions. Show a little bit of interest, please. Remember, you are competing with a lot of people in this role.
“Seems like she just wants out of her role right now and would take any job. She kept asking about relocation and what benefits we have in the first interview.”
This feels like a lack of self awareness and experience to me. Your first interview is your time to shine. It’s your time to let the company know that hiring you would be a great decision. Why ask questions like that when you don’t even have an offer letter. As an EA, your relationship with the executive is crucial. If they have the best benefits and offer amazing relocation assistance, but you don’t jibe well with your executive, all of that doesn’t matter.
“Too jumpy in career.”
This is a tough one. I know everyone has their reasons for jumping around or taking on contract roles. It’s unfortunate that it doesn’t look great. But also, I can see how being jumpy in your career could look bad and feel risky. If you didn’t last longer than a year in your past 3 jobs, what would be different here? Hiring someone is very expensive. Unless you come with rave reviews and excellent backchannels, or you have great reasons for the jumpiness that make sense, anyone can see how hiring you could be risky.
Some of these reasons are fair. Some are subjective. And some are… weird but, I mean I guess, understandable? Like I guess you wouldn’t want to look like your exec’s ex… that would be weird. But anywayyyy….
You can only control so much, so focus on what you can. Reply to the email right away. Do your homework, please. Practice telling the stories that show people how you think, what you catch, and when you know to keep your mouth shut. The question underneath a lot of these interviews is pretty simple. Can I trust this person with the stuff I don’t have time to explain, the things I might forget, and the things nobody else should know?
They don’t know you from Adam. Your stories are all they got. Make them want to hire you. Make them want to take that risk.
And always be interviewing so you can get that practice in and be ready for when the interview really matters.

